Mutualism model
Frameworks: Causal Graphs
Disciplines:
Cognitive Psychology
Programming language: R
Common-factor models assume that positively correlated variables emerge from a single latent trait. The mutualism model proposes that instead of a common factor, the positive correlations arise from beneficial, reciprocal causal interactions between the variables itself. This view can explain the same phenomena, but without the necessity of introducing a latent, unobserved trait.
Namely, the mutualism model explains the positive manifold of intelligence through the mutualistic interactions of memory systems, cognitive processes and physical actions, which all influence one another in a positive feedback loop. In addition, the mutualism model can also explain the hierarchical factor structure of intelligence, the low predictability of intelligence from early childhood performance, the integration/differentiation effect, the Flynn effect, and more. The mutualism model is therefore an alternative to the latent g-factor model for intelligence.
For an update on the mutualism model, see:
van der Maas, H. L. J., Savi, A. O., Hofman, A., Kan, K.-J., & Marsman, M. (2019). The network approach to general intelligence. In D. J. McFarland (Ed.), General and specific mental abilities (pp. 108–131). Cambridge Scholars Publishing.